Finished Werewolf XXX: Future in Stasis - GAME OVER! Town Wins! Now w/ Postgame analysis!

Status
Not open for further replies.
MDP398.png
TheFlyingPidove: I Evolved, so lets make some progress in this game. I am better at hunting now! :p
 
Please keep the roleplaying at a extremely minimal, it's just that nonsense chatter Day 1 is already much distracting to include excessive roleplay to the equation will be tons of "rubbish". Do consider others who don't have the luxury to rummage through the pile

On other note
##DISTRACT: Celever
 
I love how the last two pages show how role playing is one of the worst things that a townie can be doing right now. No you dont need to role play. What you need to do is either vote for Celever or TGK.
 
@thegrovylekid, voting (or ##VOTE) is always valid. I have no idea why you're trying to argue against that.

Celever said:
"Golly, Camo! I say it's just a bit of fun, yup yup!"
My RP is in speech marks.
1. Not really. It makes no difference whether you make a case in character or not, people should listen to what you have to say either way. There also won't be (m)any posts which are just talking about RP (i.e "haha that sounds so much like x Pokemon!"), so it just adds a little fun element to the game.
2. If you're saying stupid crap the whole game then that's fine because you're in character. Ideally people should take some things seriously, or make it clear when they're role playing (like I am when putting my RP in speech marks) to alleviate the issue.
3. It's not live mafia, so the couple of minutes spent typing up a humorous quip will not detract from scum hunting in the slightest.
4. It makes the posts a little more fluffy I guess, but it also does absolutely no harm. You need to look at what people are saying, not if they're trying to act like a Pokemon or not whilst saying it.

The above also answers @PMJ's post.

@ above conversation about voting mechanics, by "##VERB", RF means "##[insert verb here]". It's how we usually do our voting on this forum.

*Bidoof raises an eyebrow at Keeper of Night*
"Golly, I've never seen you agree with Camoclone about anything before in my life, so this is weird."
##GNAW: Keeper of Night
Click to expand...
The entire point is we wouldn't know what to take seriously or not if so many people decide to stick to rp. At this point, Day 1, it's fine, but later on will simply make you look scummy for not seriously contributing.

Celever said:
##UNGNAW: Keeper of Night
##BITE: Camoclone
"Golly, a scum slip so early!"
In the above post, Camoclone says "makes them look scummy" as opposed to "makes them scummy". This is a perfect summary of Camo's scum meta. He's very opportunistic (and he baited me there; I noticed and took it so that a newer player wouldn't make the same mistake and land us in a mislynch) and if a townie has any sort of anti-town comment or looks anti-town in any way he calls them out on it. Usually I don't look into his one liners too much, and I guess that deciding to this time around proved fruitful.
Click to expand...
That is some... Actually, no, that is the worst logic for a vote I've ever seen.
##VOTE: Celever
RDM is fine, but don't try to present a case that you don't have.

Camoclone said:
Taking note of who is viewing. This is an obvious case.
Click to expand...
I fail to understand your case at all. But the reasoning behind Celv's vote is what makes me suspicious.
 
Keeper of Night said:
@thegrovylekid, voting (or ##VOTE) is always valid. I have no idea why you're trying to argue against that.


The entire point is we wouldn't know what to take seriously or not if so many people decide to stick to rp. At this point, Day 1, it's fine, but later on will simply make you look scummy for not seriously contributing.


That is some... Actually, no, that is the worst logic for a vote I've ever seen.
##VOTE: Celever
RDM is fine, but don't try to present a case that you don't have.


I fail to understand your case at all. But the reasoning behind Celv's vote is what makes me suspicious.
Click to expand...
They have tried to completely derail any sort of logical discussion. They aren't acting pro town. And what you pointed out.
 
Roleplaying: Yes or no?
That is the only thing we have talked about so far.
Get over with it, i want to and i am going to do it.
I am getting into the werewolf feeling, wich is fun actually.
 
"Golly, the worst thing has just happened! My Internet has totally cut out, so meet phone Bidoof! I take forever to type up posts, yup yup!"

Alright, now to respond to most of this page...
Camo, the past couple pages have shown how you guys trying to oppress the role playing is the worst thing you could do. It's happening, so you'll either have to accept it or policy lynch all the role players one by one :p

Hey Keeper! I'm Celever, and I don't believe we've met! I'm really bad at making cases and lots of my early ones are totally based on metareads ;D. No but seriously, I do think it's a decent case, I just communicated it as badly as ever lol.

The main defense here is that the role players are the same few people who were doing it before we got our roles (though everyone else is free to join the vectorised PMDpocalypse of course!) which means that we would have been playing as scum before we could have possibly known we were going to be scum. The very foundation of this case, if you can call it that, is flawed, so you should try finding someone else to target, Camo! :)

And no, role play isn't compulsory. If you enjoy roleplaying though, @mordacazir, then feel free to join in! If not, then no worries either! :)
 
##UNVOTE:Celever

My vote on him was random.

Some people think it is good/not harmful to roleplay, others not. That is just an opinion and not a reason to lynch someone.

Now :

Camoclone is acting exactly like last game when he was scum. Some people might raise an eyebrow and say that this is how he always play. However, from what I have seen in the game when he was town, Camoclone did not rush to vote right away and voted someone only after he posted. That random vote on dos is similar to the first random vote he made as scum last game when he voted for EM.

TFP is also a very interesting option IMO. For his first game, posting so much without contributing is simply strange, as you would expect someone who had never played the game to be more careful.

PMJ- Not going to post anything until something extraordinary would come up? This type of play in D1 is simply unfair and you are not the only one to make it (Athena Chaos Jackal). Why the rest of the players need to post and hunt for you? If you are not scum then you are part of the town and should aim to help and find slips, put pressure, vote and share your thoughts just like any other day in the game.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top