Finished Werewolf XXX: Future in Stasis - GAME OVER! Town Wins! Now w/ Postgame analysis!
- Thread starter Reinforce
- Start date
- Status
Camoclone is using an extremely anti-town tactic (instigating worthless arguments) and has also made a terrible case on me too.
I doubt that everyone who's roleplaying is a scum. It is a possibility but a very small one considering that many players had shown their attempt to roleplay before the start of the game. There is no reason to lynch anyone simply because he/she is roleplaying. You can argue that it is disturbing or unhelpful, but not that it is a sure sign for someone to be scum.
This explodeded. ._.
##Unvote:bbninjas
I have to agree to policy lynch everyone who roleplays, TBH. It's absurdly scummy because you simply can't analyze a post properly. If @Reinforce doesn't forbid it, I'll either push for their lynches or get lynched trying; and if I don't manage to do it I'd be happier than ever to be taken out of this game, since it would be heavily advantageous to scum and extremely unfair.
##Vote: TheGrovyleKid
LynchAllRolePlayers (LARP)
I'm literally not making another post until @Reinforce forbids RP or all of you cut it.
##Unvote:bbninjas
I have to agree to policy lynch everyone who roleplays, TBH. It's absurdly scummy because you simply can't analyze a post properly. If @Reinforce doesn't forbid it, I'll either push for their lynches or get lynched trying; and if I don't manage to do it I'd be happier than ever to be taken out of this game, since it would be heavily advantageous to scum and extremely unfair.
##Vote: TheGrovyleKid
LynchAllRolePlayers (LARP)
I'm literally not making another post until @Reinforce forbids RP or all of you cut it.
...
LARP stands for Live Action Role Play. That's a little bit hilarious given what your post is about
Is it really a huge issue for currently only 3 players to do a little bit of role play in their posts? It's @TheFlyingPidove's first game and roleplaying seems to be a good way for him to get warmed into the game since it's something more familiar for him. As for TGK and I, it's just to provide a little bit more fun and enjoyment for us, and it only derails the thread if you keep bringing up having issues with it (again using @TwistedTurtwig's RP of Hagrid in your game @Luispipe8).
Also, I would argue that it actually helps to read the players who are roleplaying. If their roleplaying it could mean that they are panicking under pressure which is a huge scumtell.
Can you read and analyze Camo's posts properly ?
How about the none existed posts from inactive players and all the "I'm not playing in D1" players?
Is that more fair than to actually post, share thoughts while giving a non serious sentence of RP here and there?
I find this funny because LARP stands for Live Action Role Play.
Missed out the key word of the last sentence, so quoted and fixed...
LARP stands for Live Action Role Play. That's a little bit hilarious given what your post is about
Is it really a huge issue for currently only 3 players to do a little bit of role play in their posts? It's @TheFlyingPidove's first game and roleplaying seems to be a good way for him to get warmed into the game since it's something more familiar for him. As for TGK and I, it's just to provide a little bit more fun and enjoyment for us, and it only derails the thread if you keep bringing up having issues with it (again using @TwistedTurtwig's RP of Hagrid in your game @Luispipe8).
Also, I would argue that it actually helps to read the players who are roleplaying. If their roleplaying slips it could mean that they are panicking under pressure which is a huge scumtell.
.So that this isn't totally worthless:
QFT
If they are town they wouldn't be roleplaying. If they are town then they are playing against their win con. It's a win win because it's obvious they will flip scum.
No need to do that. Just lynch them because they are scum.
Or, alternately, we're town and trying to enjoy the game.
... The LARP thing is an awful coincidence.
Don't compare Camo's playstyle with RP. That's how he plays and isn't affected by his role's character. Because of roleplay, we already know Celever's Bidoof. It's a small thing, yeah, but it's a start. What if he claimed doctor, seer, journalist, etc? That's info that scum shouldn't have known.
And yes, you can analyze Camo's posts because he's the one writing them. If you RP, as someone already stated, you can have the most awful scumslip and say "no, no, that was part of the act". It's the perfect disclaimer for scum.
Don't compare Camo's playstyle with RP. That's how he plays and isn't affected by his role's character. Because of roleplay, we already know Celever's Bidoof. It's a small thing, yeah, but it's a start. What if he claimed doctor, seer, journalist, etc? That's info that scum shouldn't have known.
And yes, you can analyze Camo's posts because he's the one writing them. If you RP, as someone already stated, you can have the most awful scumslip and say "no, no, that was part of the act". It's the perfect disclaimer for scum.
How do you analyse a post that's just a vote?
By how that vote fits into the other posts of the writer and the rest of the players tgk.
Calling policy lynch on every roleplayer. Camo is as boring as ever, but he's right on the roleplaying part. It doesn't matter whether they are scum or not, it's simply bad here. No offense RPers, but that's not how you play WW. It's already a game of lying and deceit, the last thing we need is someone saying "But I was just roleplaying!". It's already hard enough for town, don't make it any harder.
Camo fitting his scummy self more than his townie one is a point we can follow afterwards.
##VOTE: thegrovylekid
Calling policy lynch on every roleplayer. Camo is as boring as ever, but he's right on the roleplaying part. It doesn't matter whether they are scum or not, it's simply bad here. No offense RPers, but that's not how you play WW. It's already a game of lying and deceit, the last thing we need is someone saying "But I was just roleplaying!". It's already hard enough for town, don't make it any harder.
Camo fitting his scummy self more than his townie one is a point we can follow afterwards.
##VOTE: thegrovylekid
"Golly, it sure was funny though, yup yup!"
It's not actually affected how I play either. I'm playing exactly the same, just with a few "golly"s, "yup yup"s and "sure does"s thrown in there! It just adds a small extra element to it, and taking on Bidoof's personality of childish curiosity is perfect for me since I'm a little bit like that IRL
.And yes, you know that I'm Bidoof, but that's about as far as it would go. I did think about the situation before I decided to imitate my character. I'm not Magnezone the cop or some sort of doctor character (if Super Mystery Dungeon is included in this flavour that'd be Audino). You can't really link my role's affects to just my Pokemon species, so it's fine.
A.K.A meta-reading A.K.A doing exactly what I just got called out for by Keeper of Night, right? >~>
And as mentioned before, (this also answers @Chaos Jackal's post above) we're making it clear when we're RPing and when we're not. This means that if you find a scumslip the excuse will be totally invalid, and since the RP itself is mostly just for humorous purposes as opposed to actually creating stalwart cases, this hypothetical confusion could never occur.
Most of Camo's posts are meaningless votes or total fluff "I've got a case in my head guys, you need to follow it if you're town!"
If a player "townslip" by his RP, another can scumslip by his RP. In other words, there is no impact on the game whatsoever as every player can scumslip, accidentally reveal his/her role or appear scummy, regardless of said player being roleplaying or not. If someone's going to scumslip and tell it is part of his/her roleplay, I am not going to believe him as you cannot control on what you slip and determent that you only slip things when you are not roleplaying.
Yeah can we stop the role playing? I'm here to play Mafia, not an RPG. If y'all want to role play make up some mystery dungeon style RPG and play it.
As for everything that's happened, Camo is hard to read so I've got nothing to push here. I read him as town early game last game so I was wrong. If he's not dead by maybe Night 3 then he's probably scum
Celever, TFP and TGK are all being annoying with their role playing and I'd be happy with any of their lynches
Alas I will hold my vote though for now I'm gonna try to be a little less trigger happy like I was last game
As for everything that's happened, Camo is hard to read so I've got nothing to push here. I read him as town early game last game so I was wrong. If he's not dead by maybe Night 3 then he's probably scum
Celever, TFP and TGK are all being annoying with their role playing and I'd be happy with any of their lynches
Alas I will hold my vote though for now
I'm gonna try to be a little less trigger happy like I was last game 
ugh, fine. I'll come up with some sort of PMD RP after all of this is over. I also love how you guys are following Camo, a person with an actual, albeit weak, case on him, to lynch people who have not acted scummy outside of Role Playing.
Get it together, guys...
Get it together, guys...
- Status