Finished Mafia XXXVII: Celever's School Grades ~ Game Over!

[Squirtle Squad]

Why did you unvote Jesi?

I can see her being town amidst everything, and it's true that part of how she's playing is how she has been known to play as town, even if she's doing similarly scummy things, obviously if it continues / gets worse then she'll get my vote in a flash.

 

[simsands]

I can see her being town amidst everything, and it's true that part of how she's playing is how she has been known to play as town, even if she's doing similarly scummy things, obviously if it continues / gets worse then she'll get my vote in a flash.

Who do you think we should lynch, instead?

 

[Squirtle Squad]

I think this post explains well the case on Robin:



As for the Wailord case: I think that when scums want to jump on a wagon they indeed feel like justifying their vote by echoing, but townies can do that too. Same thing goes when scums try to hop off a dead wagon, only here, it is more common for scum, imo, than town to echo when they unvote. Not sure if that's the main point of your case, but it is not something I feel that is stronger than the points on Robin and Jesi.

Why do you say it's sort of a case? You mean the case is not good? Why?

Ok i've got more than just this, but so far all of scattered's posts have been super short, one line usually at most.

He's maintained a strong activity level which is usual for him, but his posts aren't often these one liners.

Also through reading his posts, he's playing Devil's advocate in almost every single post, not actually contributing his own opinion, just questioning the posts of everyone elses, which looks like a contribution but isn't really putting forward his own ideas.

The above two posts show a subtle buddying of Wailord. Defending the case against @bbninjas

I will quote more soon, just as soon as the housework is complete.

##vote: scattered mind

(also he's never been scum before if i recall correctly - bound to happen eventually )

Also is there a way to filter through posts quickly without reading through every single page? When you guys do an ISO is that just you going through and multi quoting every single post by that person after having flicked through every page?? Or is there a way to do this automatically?

 

[Camoclone]

Use the search button and filter for their name alone.

Place your votes people we are running out of time.

 

[VinculumStellarum]

Also through reading his posts, he's playing Devil's advocate in almost every single post, not actually contributing his own opinion, just questioning the posts of everyone elses, which looks like a contribution but isn't really putting forward his own ideas.

This is what he was doing last game, remember that.

The above two posts show a subtle buddying of Wailord. Defending the case against @bbninjas

The second one was actually him questioning how I'd described BB's case on Wailord. I wouldn't personally call that post buddying, but I can see why on the first one.

Camo, I sure will.

##Vote: Robin Aisaga
Not moving this vote until you tell us what "information" you hinted at earlier.

 

[NinjaPenguin]

FoS on any veteran attacking Camo right now. You should know how he plays.
I don't like Robin's "vital knowledge"; it seems like another desperate move to save himself. If it really existed, you should have told us by now.
##VOTE: Robin Aisaga
Please tell us your info.
P.S.

also he's never been scum before if i recall correctly - bound to happen eventually

He was scum in Dimensional Shift.

 

[TheAnticipationEevee]

I think Im going to have to vote Robin.

for now as his lynch seems to be beneficial for town to get more info. I am personally confused with his alignment, and probably many other people so end the confusion somehow?

(I was gonna vote, then saw Ninja's post, so just in case I accidentally hammer, I'm just not going to vote for him until he gets a chance to respond to stuff).

 

[VinculumStellarum]

If you place your vote, Robin will be at L-2 or L-1.

 

[bbninjas]

Yet another OMGUS-like vote

Is OMGUS scummy?

Ok i've got more than just this, but so far all of scattered's posts have been super short, one line usually at most.

As Jesi mentioned, I think this is standard SM play.

The above two posts show a subtle buddying of Wailord. Defending the case against @bbninjas

Though, agreed, some good SM/Wailord buddying for [Future Reference] here.

I think Im going to have to vote Robin.

You sound you like don't particularly like the lynch. Who do you think is better?

for now as his lynch seems to be beneficial for town to get more info.

How?

 

[bbninjas]

Robin lynch summary please?

'cause right now I think it's rubbish compared to Wailord or PP lynches.

 

[Camoclone]

Yes OMGUS is scummy especially when it is every one of your "cases" / votes.

 

[bbninjas]

Yes OMGUS is scummy especially when it is every one of your "cases" / votes.

Wasn't really asking you but sure

 

[bbninjas]

Okay, reading back, Robin is really all over the place. Could be scum, could be town. I'm not feeling particularly convinced either way. So... a decent lynch option, but I think that Professor P or Wailord will more likely net scum.

 

[VinculumStellarum]

Is OMGUS scummy?

It can be, but it can also show annoyance in the player. I see Robin's as the annoyed kind, though.

 

[NinjaPenguin]

Okay, reading back, Robin is really all over the place. Could be scum, could be town. I'm not feeling particularly convinced either way. So... a decent lynch option, but I think that Professor P or Wailord will more likely net scum.

What points does the PP lynch have? It just feels like scum trying to push a lynch on an experienced player.

 

[bbninjas]

It can be, but it can also show annoyance in the player. I see Robin's as the annoyed kind, though.

I don't understand why you would quote things like this and point out the obvious potential tells, but won't actually give a solid stance on what your observation actually means for their alignment until you someone calls you out for it.

 

[Camoclone]

Wasn't really asking you but sure

You asked this so I decided to give you one of the many reasons. Another reason is his reaction to a single RVS vote.

Robin lynch summary please?

 

[bbninjas]

What points does the PP lynch have? It just feels like scum trying to push a lynch on an experienced player.

Here's the scummy things I've noticed about PP:
- Feeding the Jesi lynch (which I think is a little off for town PP)
- Moreso because he's stayed on the Robin lynch for its entire duration (which I should note for [Future Reference])
- This post pinged my scumdar particularly because I think that Robin's actions were characteristic, and at least not "completely out of character". I'd expect better from town PP tbh. This is where it starts to feel like tunneling.

Which isn't as much as I was thinking, so cool! Thanks for getting me to recheck. :>

So, Wailord > Robin > Professor P, then.

And ##UNVOTE ##VOTE: Wailord

 

[VinculumStellarum]

I don't understand why you would quote things like this and point out the obvious potential tells, but won't actually give a solid stance on what your observation actually means for their alignment until you someone calls you out for it.

To be honest, I don't even know why I do this myself. I just point out what I see.

 

[bbninjas]

To be honest, I don't even know why I do this myself. I just point out what I see.

Consider making conclusions from your observations in future. That's one way you can improve your game.