Finished Mafia XXXVII: Celever's School Grades ~ Game Over!

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm confused as to why Camo decides to comment a 'yes' to several questions and say his internet was not working, but instead he could just ignore the game as a whole until the internet comes back??

Also anyone besides me notice that Sceptile's answers are always very vague like in a purposeful way kind of?
 
There's nothing wrong with trying to explain your posts in more detail, though. Why do you feel the way you do about X? What do you think could come from it? Things like this will help you, I think. ^v^
 
Tsm not being aware to the fact I asked him a question and asking me to repeat it tells that he was not paying attention to the game, because I tagged him several times throughout the last day asking him to answer the question. The other explanation is that he simply ignored me, which I can't tell what is worse.
 
I can only wonder what took you so long to response to my many tags of you and ask where the question is, even after you posted in thread without actually reacting to any post where I tagged you.
 
Day 1 i wasnt available a lot since i was doing projects and didnt have the time to post and wait for responses
Day 2 was basically an meaningless day since we. Already lnew to lynch robin and dont want to add anything at the moment
 
Day 2 was basically an meaningless day since we. Already lnew to lynch robin and dont want to add anything at the moment

Why do you think it was not necessary to add anything at that moment? Did you read my comment on that day that we should try and gain more info? No one said that we didn't need to add anything, yet there were players like me and Jesi who agreed that people should stop voting Robin so the day can be used for more info to gain. That comment of yours only supports my suspicion that you are not paying enough attention to the game.
 
I feel that while TSM and Jabber are scummy in different levels (in my opinion), in "the background" Jesi is also scummy for the old points that were given about her, as well as the fact that she did not bother to response to them after they were brought again by simsands. Also, she is not scumhunting, and keeps supporting current points made by others.

Just look at her posts throughout this day:

OH MY GOD IT'S PEDRO!! :D I actually want to draw something for this now! I'm actually pretty happy about this. It's even similar to what Benjamin Cloviet had last game! *dances a bit*

Fluff

The Robin thing was him acting rude and sarcastic to try a new strategy (I think; that's what he said), which ended up digging his hole further.
Robin bussing PP was him using his own role and changing the wording to paint someone as scum, which PP ended up claiming he had, but he ended up getting lynched because he claimed it.
The Drama vs Performing Arts fiasco is directly linked to this, as Robin had Drama and PP had Performing Arts.
Me doing things wrong was playing like my Mafia XXXV self, though I do think I've improved on this.
Other than this, there were suspicions on TSM like described above (as well as for his agitated mannerisms, at least how I was reading them), Inferno for having edited a post (not once, not twice, but I believe three times), and... I think that's it. Did I miss anything, aside from what TAE's posted?

Telling someone who subbed what happened last day.

I doubt we'll get those without some sort of prodding.

Anyways, we need some leads, stat. Unfortunately though, there's barely anything to go off of. @TheSceptileMaster, why are you avoiding Scattered's questions?

Talking about the vote count.
Mention that we need leads.. "there is nothing to go off of" - asking TSM why he is not answering my question, which is actually appreciated.

All this in one post. One big post, but with little substance.

Could you go into more detail about why you think DOS is scummy? A simple "yes" doesn't give me enough reason to look into her.

A legitimate question.

I did notice this. It could possibly be just newness, but I think it could more likely be a scumbuddy telling him to keep shut. @TheSceptileMaster, how come your answers are vague? Is there a specific reason?

There's nothing wrong with trying to explain your posts in more detail, though. Why do you feel the way you do about X? What do you think could come from it? Things like this will help you, I think. ^v^


I don't think you're looking into it too much. If it weren't that way, I think that same point would be worded differently.

Supporting an existing lead.

Again, the biggest point in Jesi's favor is that this is the way she acted when she was town. However, there are other legitimate points on Simsands' case that are not related to Jesi's meta. Her doubt on the existence of a silencer in this setup, and her role fish about trying to guess what school subjects can be considered gay.
 
There are less than 24 hours for the day to end. I don't think Camo is going to have his Internet back soon to present his case, so if that's what everyone is waiting for, please note that you should probably put that aside and try to figure out who are you going to vote for. There is no going back from voting today, so we need to agree with each other who's going to be lynched before actually voting. Speak up.
 
We have more than 24 hours but you are right. My internet isn't returning any time soon and thus I can't read back effectively. People shouldn't be waiting for me.
 
I was going by the timer. Perhaps it is not working right for me from some reason but it shows 23 hours left.
 
The timer shows the same for me. @scattered mind

Right now, I don't see any other legit vote other than Jesi, and she doesn't seem to be planning to change my mind. As things are looking now, I don't see myself voting for anyone else, but I'll hold my vote until tomorrow.
 
Since not much else is happening, here's the case on Jesi, summed up.


Contradition. Describes how new players panic, and uses that as her main reason to pin him as scum.
Not entirely sure what I was thinking there.

Afraid of pressure.
Why wouldn't I be? I don't like being made to feel like I'm doing something wrong. It makes me feel bad, and to an extent, stupid, so that's why I'd be afraid.

Referring to town as 'they', like someone who wasn't town would do.
I worded it talking about town as a whole. That was the best way I thought I could word it at the time.

WIFOM. AtE.
AtE is just something that happens from me naturally. Not sure what exactly I can say about the WIFOM, though.

Backpedaling her TSM vote to join the new hot bandwagon.
I actually wanted to switch my vote earlier, but I didn't, because if I did, I'd have been called out for throwing my vote around, and I didn't want that, so I played like I was still interested in the TSM lynch.

Afraid of being called out for backpedaling. Major AtE. Slight rolefish.
1) See "Afraid of Pressure."
2) See "WIFOM. AtE."
3) Not sure where the rolefish is in the specific quote.

Silencer's are quite common, and usually belong to scum. The only ones who should be able to 'highly doubt' the existence of a silencer during D1 are the scum members.
My logic was that after how the silencer got used in my game, the ability would have been taken out to make things fair. I sure wouldn't want to be in TAE's position, not even being able to talk for most of my playtime after being so excited to sub in.

Bandwagon.
I placed my vote to pressure him. Other players do this and get no trouble for it.

Backpedal.
What was I supposed to do, keep my vote somewhere I didn't feel was right to keep it?

Role fishing.
I realized what I did was wrong and tried to take it back.

And when she realizes that, quickly distances herself.
Is there something wrong with making a mistake and trying to right it?

So you're not reading him as scum, but you're still trying to get him lynched?
Yes, because I felt there were other points against him that justified a lynch.

Stating the obvious.
What if there were a case where someone like me couldn't pick up on that flavour and instead read it as legitimate misplacement of the role, not remembering the role PM? I find it quite strange that last night's kill had no flip, either. If the nightkill is always like this, I'd honestly be a bit disappointed.

Bandwagon.
How's that a bandwagon? I didn't even place a vote! >:/

Then defends Camo.
To my defense, what was listed against Camo was stuff that falls under his normal play.

Feels the need for defending herself against criticism against all players.
I felt I had to.

I feel that while TSM and Jabber are scummy in different levels (in my opinion), in "the background" Jesi is also scummy for the old points that were given about her, as well as the fact that she did not bother to response to them after they were brought again by simsands. Also, she is not scumhunting, and keeps supporting current points made by others.
1) Earlier this game, I was under fire for responding to everything (at least how I saw and remember it), so I tried to change that, and now I'm back under fire?
2) Haven't been scumhunting because school's been in the way.

Am I not allowed to be happy that a possession of my favourite OC returned in a Mafia game? Am I just supposed to play like an emotionless robot or something?

Telling someone who subbed what happened last day.
This is a scumtell why? He asked for a summary, so I gave him one.

Talking about the vote count.
Sorry! I was trying to contribute! >_<"

Mention that we need leads.. "there is nothing to go off of" - asking TSM why he is not answering my question, which is actually appreciated.
^v^
I can't tell what your stance is on the first part of the quote directly above, though.

All this in one post. One big post, but with little substance.
Well, I thought it was something decent.

[/quote]A legitimate question.[/quote]
I've noticed Camo's been a lot less explanatory with his posts this game. He hasn't really gone in-depth with what he thinks.

Supporting an existing lead.
I don't really see the problem with this, except for maybe having done scumhunting instead.

Again, the biggest point in Jesi's favor is that this is the way she acted when she was town. However, there are other legitimate points on Simsands' case that are not related to Jesi's meta. Her doubt on the existence of a silencer in this setup, and her role fish about trying to guess what school subjects can be considered gay.
I explained the silencer and role fish parts, so I don't think I need to say it again.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top