Finished Mafia XXXVIII: Battle for the Republic (Congratulations Darth Sidious!)

[Robin Aisaga]

You have claimed the same amount of information that quaking has. You were called out for giving false information just last page.

I didn't claim my ability. The first vote count of day 1 revealed my double vote. It's not information I desired to keep behind. I don't see how that would help town anyway. Last page I did mention jedi when instead I should've said town. It's not worth making a commotion out of it.

Do you want to tell us why it's unlikely that he's an indie with a safe claim?

quaking's ability does sound like an indie ability

No that should be clear, I'm not sure why you say that because by now you should also realize that quaking's ability doesn't sound like an indie ability.

 

[simsands]

No that should be clear, I'm not sure why you say that because by now you should also realize that quaking's ability doesn't sound like an indie ability.

Well, the flavor he posted doesn't sound like an indie, of course. That's not what I'm saying.

 

[Jabberwock]

It's a bit weird that Robin's activity picks up after he's put under a limelight. Like scattered said, I'm also picking up undertones of panic in a lot of what he's saying. IIRC Robin usually reacts this way to his name being thrown around, though––I don't think that's OMGUS, or at least not abnormal OMGUS.

Before his lynch, Rainy was completely convinced that his flip would get us valuable information on TGK. He implied that it would prove that TGK is scum. Did we ever find out why exactly he thought that?

 

[thegrovylekid]

BTW- Notice how TGK has disappeared once people agreed not to focus on him for now. This is very scummy, considering he was rushed to defend himself asap after Rainy flipped town.

I'm actually extremely sick and spent most of the past two days sleeping or trying to sleep.

Before his lynch, Rainy was completely convinced that his flip would get us valuable information on TGK. He implied that it would prove that TGK is scum. Did we ever find out why exactly he thought that?

Honestly that was just Rainy OMGUSing, then backing it up with some good ol' AtE. (Everyone should be voting TGK right now, unless everyone is Mafia (I'm all alone )

Give me a day or two snd I'll br able to formulate thoughtd sgsin.

 

[VinculumStellarum]

I didn't claim my ability. The first vote count of day 1 revealed my double vote. It's not information I desired to keep behind. I don't see how that would help town anyway. Last page I did mention jedi when instead I should've said town. It's not worth making a commotion out of it.




No that should be clear, I'm not sure why you say that because by now you should also realize that quaking's ability doesn't sound like an indie ability.

You still technically claimed the same amount of info, though, as Quaking's claim was small and brief. Vote weight can help town know not to place as many votes to avoid a scum hammer.

I'm going to try my very best to improve my activity. This from me is unacceptable.

 

[bbninjas]

It's a bit weird that Robin's activity picks up after he's put under a limelight. Like scattered said, I'm also picking up undertones of panic in a lot of what he's saying. IIRC Robin usually reacts this way to his name being thrown around, though––I don't think that's OMGUS, or at least not abnormal OMGUS.

I agree with this, except that I don't find it particularly weird that Robin gets more active after being under the limelight. I think that's standard across a number of players.

 

[Scorched Feathers]

I agree with this, except that I don't find it particularly weird that Robin gets more active after being under the limelight. I think that's standard across a number of players.

Basically this. It's quite natural to defend yourself when accused of something, even when you don't normally post a lot.

I literally have no leads right now and I hate it. Didn't expect Rainy to actually flip town and will wait for TGK's defence.

 

[bbninjas]

I literally have no leads right now and I hate it. Didn't expect Rainy to actually flip town and will wait for TGK's defence.

I believe TGK's first post for this Day phase was his defense.

 

[Scorched Feathers]

I believe TGK's first post for this Day phase was his defense.

I think he meant in a couple days (i.e. before this day phase is over and when he's a bit better) he'll make a post. Otherwise, oh dear.

 

[Scattered mind]

You still technically claimed the same amount of info, though, as Quaking's claim was small and brief. Vote weight can help town know not to place as many votes to avoid a scum hammer.

I'm going to try my very best to improve my activity. This from me is unacceptable.

Any thoughts on Robin?

I think he meant in a couple days (i.e. before this day phase is over and when he's a bit better) he'll make a post. Otherwise, oh dear.

What do you mean?


I think that lynching quaking today would be best, as he is less active and aggressive. However, I also consider lynching Robin because they are unusually panicked, while being less emotional. Usually AtE is considered scummy but in this case I actually remember them very emotional as town. So they are panicked and omgusy, but also seems calculated.

Yeah, it is complicated.

 

[VinculumStellarum]

Any thoughts on Robin?

\He's being a lot more logical compared to last game, reminding me of his OitC play, but when under pressure over on Page 29, he's acting a lot like he did in XXXVII, but more toned down. When people say he's panicky, I can see this as well.

If quakingpunch were to commit mafia suicide then I'm not that eager to stop him.

This is a little strange to me, as I believe any townie would want as much discussion time as possible. Why wouldn't you want to stop him, @Robin Aisaga?

 

[Robin Aisaga]

I am actually trying to make my posts less emotional to become a better player. The words omgus, AtE and panicking are repeatedly used against me and it's getting a little tiresome. I try to be more objective, however taking an offensive/defensive stand when I see myself being unreasonably targeted is not a point I decided to let go yet.

This is a little strange to me, as I believe any townie would want as much discussion time as possible. Why wouldn't you want to stop him, @Robin Aisaga?

I realize that, but if quaking is mafia and he lynches himself I'm simply not too bothered because overall our situation will be improved.

 

[bbninjas]

I realize that, but if quaking is mafia and he lynches himself I'm simply not too bothered because overall our situation will be improved.

It's actually better if we had more discussion and still lynched quaking, if he is mafia, instead of him lynching himself. The final outcome will still occur, but we got more time to discuss other options.

 

[Squirtle Squad]

Day 4 Vote Count

quakingpunch73 5 (bbninjas, NinjaPenguin, Vracken, Robin Aisaga, lord of da rings, Robin Aisaga, )L-2
NinjaPenguin 1 (quakingpunch73, )
Robin Aisaga 1 (simsands,

There are 12 players alive therefore 7 votes are required to lynch.

Day 4 will end on Sunday the 18th of December at 7am.

There are 23 hours left of Day 4

 

[bbninjas]

@quakingpunch73

Can you please claim full?

 

[Scattered mind]

@Scorched Feathers ? Hello?

Everyone in general- hello?

 

[Scattered mind]

@quakingpunch73 - why do you ignore the game ?

 

[NinjaPenguin]

Everyone in general- hello?

I'm here. There just isn't much that I can respond to. Quaking isn't really defending himself (or claiming, he's had plenty of time to do that). I think he's trying to do that to reduce discussion as much as possible.
I still think Robin is a good lynch option after Quaking, especially when seeing simsands's points.

There are less than ten hours until the lynch, and it would be good to hear everyone's opinions before it happens.

 

[Lorde]

Quaking isn't doing anything, or defending himself. The only logical reason why is he wants this to go on faster, and wants to stop discussion for the day. The problem is it's working. As with NinjaPenguin, there's just nothing to respond to at the moment, since no ones talking.

My opinions haven't really changed on lynching Quaking, as he's yet to make a claim or defend himself in a while, when he's likely the lynch candidate for the day. I just find his lack of defensive or even effort to stay in the game strange. If he's town but he's not gonna help us, why keep him around?

 

[NinjaPenguin]

If he's town but he's not gonna help us, why keep him around?

At this point, the ratio has progressed tot he point where we really can't afford to lose any more townies. We can't lynch on policy at this point, since a mislynch would bring us to LYLO.