Finished Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Members win!

[Cobalt Phoenix]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

Geez Camo, maybe stop flip-flopping between the two of us? I Why am I lurking? I'm not, I was at work. It's kind of hard to clean restrooms AND type replies to your allegations . There's not enough evidence to accuse either KoN or myself of scum-like behavior. Chillax, bro. We have plenty of time. Now to read all of those posts :S.

 

[Keeper of Night]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

Geez Camo, maybe stop flip-flopping between the two of us? I Why am I lurking? I'm not, I was at work. It's kind of hard to clean restrooms AND type replies to your allegations . There's not enough evidence to accuse either KoN or myself of scum-like behavior. Chillax, bro. We have plenty of time. Now to read all of those posts :S.

Actually, there is evidence against me. Given my rather vague claim and Drohn's accusations.
The evidence against you is pretty much the same against Drohn, plus the fact you were rather quick to claim and were leaning on it a while.

Without including myself, I vote for lynching either TheGuy or CP today. Guy simply because town should not be asking the role blockers to claim.

 

[WanderingWolf]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

because I would think this Porygon would have some supernatural ability to ban members, and wouldn't just hack into the admins account, and even if it was talking about Porygon,

It's a Porygon, it's literally a man-made machine that could hack into computers Just look at Porygon-X's avatar. I think it's more hacking then it is Lick.

 

[Machamp The Champion]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

because I would think this Porygon would have some supernatural ability to ban members, and wouldn't just hack into the admins account, and even if it was talking about Porygon,

It's a Porygon, it's literally a man-made machine that could hack into computers Just look at Porygon-X's avatar. I think it's more hacking then it is Lick.

... Wow, do I feel stupid. Still, as I said before, Keeper is scummy enough that I think we should lynch him anyway.

 

[rev3rsor]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

Just to me, Keeper's effect ("You may be alerted when other players target you at night.") just seems fishy to me, mainly because of the 'you may be'. I'm not saying it's impossible but I doubt PMJ would make a role that "may" work.
So just for now ##KEEP: Keeper of Night

 

[Athena]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

Wah, you guys post a lot over the weekends. Guess it makes sense that most people would have a lot of free time over the weekends. >_>

I still don't think KoN is the SK at all. That says, his waffling and vague role claiming could be a sign of something else, since it doesn't actually seem like something that would be a real role. So, an FoS there, and while I'm at it, one for TheGuy too for his jab for the roleblocker to claim. Don't really follow the points on CP, but maybe that's just sympathy because I'm busy over the weekends too and therefore less likely to post and be active and therefore have like 50 posts to catch up on...

Camo's aggression reads inno to me, but maybe that's because I'm used to aggressive innos. As much as his aggression makes me uncomfortable and it's not a play style I follow myself, it doesn't really mean much in terms of affiliation from what I'm used to.

 

[Camoclone]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

Geez Camo, maybe stop flip-flopping between the two of us? I Why am I lurking? I'm not, I was at work. It's kind of hard to clean restrooms AND type replies to your allegations . There's not enough evidence to accuse either KoN or myself of scum-like behavior. Chillax, bro. We have plenty of time. Now to read all of those posts :S.

He still has yet to contribute anything. If you look at his posts about 10% of them have substance.

 

[Camoclone]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

KoN is scummy but CP is more scummy... His posts have no substance if you look back.

 

[Camoclone]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

Here are all of Cobalt Phoenix's posts:

Spoiler

>LOL PRAISE ME
Oh boy, Sonicmoj is probably the annoying kid.

No contribution.

Whoa. Less than 2 hours in and Champ is already "voting" (or whatever Swagger actually does) for Camo. Confused status: kinda. If Machamp isn't actually voting, could he be a role blocker and/or a town drunk of some kind?

Alright here we see a confused person. Hasn't RVS'd apparently.

Cobalt and Celever what do you have to say? Lurkers...

That feel when you leave for league and other things and don't have WiFi for the entire time. I just got home, so allow me to read the thread before giving an opinion. Okay?

No contribution.

@Theguy, to be honest, it's not like Drohn was around for "The Age of Kronar." That was like 2009-2011 ish. I highly doubt he researched the background to be able to forge a fake role description. I'm gonna hold off on voting for anyone until more evidence is presented.

No contribution.

Champ, I googled Random Voting Stage and found this link for RQS. Your Google-fu needs work, son.

No contribution.

Yeah, Guy. I did a tad a research and he was 2006-2009. To those wondering, Kronar was someone who mainly stuck to the chatrooms. He started the "adding random funny bits of chatlog into your bio" meme that still continues today. Kronar tended to be funny at all times while active. I can't think of anything else that's memorable about him, so if anyone else was around then, please feel free to add.

No contribution.

Instead of killing KoN if there's a roleblocker they should target him tonight.

I can agree with that. Drohn, I'm sorry. I kinda have to go with the majority here. There's a lot of evidence pulling me towards ya.
##Lynch: Drohn

Can we get a vote count?

Hammered and obvious bandwagoning.

May I ask what "hammered" means? Also, 100% townie. If y'all would like my role pm, let me know. It's funny, I have a role, but it feels like it's worse than a vanilla townie. I dunno.

Why didn't he google this? No contribution.

It's not like I counted before hand. I even asked for a vote count.

Okay, incoming best role pm EVAR!!!111!

Role: Meaty
Alignment: Members

You are Meaty, a member of PokeBeach Forums. You heard a rumor that WPM was meatier than you. That is obviously not true, but you're rebelling because it's fun.

Passive Effect: Meaty
If you would be killed at night, you will die at the end of the next day instead of the end of the current night. During that day, your vote weight is zero.

Win Condition: All non-Members eliminated

Best thing ever Amirite?

Also Champ, I'm actually not new to this. My first game was back in 2009's WW4. I've just had a lot of random crap impeding my chances of getting back into this.

How is this worse than a VT? Why claim when I'm the only one attacking him?

Camoclone said
>CP is probably scum
I just wanted to protect myself. Nothing more.

Just defending himself no contribution.

It's true. I CAN"T prove it. So let's flip it then. YOU can't prove you're not scum either, can you? If you can, present your evidence.

AtE...

Because lynching another townie makes a WHOLE LOT OF SENSE. If I was scum, don't you think I would try to CONCEAL my role, instead of just throwing it out in the open willy-nilly? I did it, so y'all could get off my backs. First the anonymous message is targeting me, and now, you are too. I'm sure we're still in RQS, but I have no reason to be nervous. I know I'm innocent.

Key word here is another townie. We haven't lynched a townie yet. And extreme AtE.

I'm a defensive person, thank you very much. I'll stop if that makes you feel better. And actually, it's two peeps. The Anon from the Night 1 results and now you.

2 people is not a lot. Defending himself with no real contribution.

Geez Camo, maybe stop flip-flopping between the two of us? I Why am I lurking? I'm not, I was at work. It's kind of hard to clean restrooms AND type replies to your allegations . There's not enough evidence to accuse either KoN or myself of scum-like behavior. Chillax, bro. We have plenty of time. Now to read all of those posts :S.

No contribution just defense. And there is more than enough evidence to lynch both of you/.

Make sure you read all of that. It is very important. You will get a overwhelming theme after a while.

 

[Athena]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

Man, even *I*'ve been contributing more than that. >_>

 

[GM DracLord]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

Just to me, Keeper's effect ("You may be alerted when other players target you at night.") just seems fishy to me, mainly because of the 'you may be'. I'm not saying it's impossible but I doubt PMJ would make a role that "may" work.
So just for now ##KEEP: Keeper of Night

PMJ could do that to kepp the game balance reducing the power of certain roles.. KoN probably have an active ability to accompany the passive

 

[rev3rsor]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

Wah, you guys post a lot over the weekends. Guess it makes sense that most people would have a lot of free time over the weekends. >_>

I still don't think KoN is the SK at all. That says, his waffling and vague role claiming could be a sign of something else, since it doesn't actually seem like something that would be a real role. So, an FoS there, and while I'm at it, one for TheGuy too for his jab for the roleblocker to claim. Don't really follow the points on CP, but maybe that's just sympathy because I'm busy over the weekends too and therefore less likely to post and be active and therefore have like 50 posts to catch up on...

Camo's aggression reads inno to me, but maybe that's because I'm used to aggressive innos. As much as his aggression makes me uncomfortable and it's not a play style I follow myself, it doesn't really mean much in terms of affiliation from what I'm used to.

It's not actually my weekend; it's Monday (exam week yay!) for me
IMO if KoN has to fakeclaim there must be a good reason, and something that he's hiding. I still think that his role isn't quite legit, despite what Draclord suggested; just the "may" sounds shifty to me (dunno if it's just me or not, because I usually notice these things a lot). Though depending on what comes up later I might be convinced to unvote, but I'm staying for now.

and camo is always like this from experience. I basically skim his posts, and try to pay attention to what's important.

 

[alex]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

Geez Camo, maybe stop flip-flopping between the two of us? I Why am I lurking? I'm not, I was at work. It's kind of hard to clean restrooms AND type replies to your allegations . There's not enough evidence to accuse either KoN or myself of scum-like behavior. Chillax, bro. We have plenty of time. Now to read all of those posts :S.

He still has yet to contribute anything. If you look at his posts about 10% of them have substance.

KoN is scummy but CP is more scummy... His posts have no substance if you look back.

Camo, you've played too many Werewolf games to not know that insubstantial posts simply means a new player, werewolf or town or indie, and that it tells you nothing about their role.

Only well thought out long posts with no actual opinion are worth analyzing this way.

 

[Keeper of Night]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

I don't believe I've voted yet.
##VOTE: Cobalt Phoenix

Doesn't contribute, and at the first sign of an attack is all for claiming. Ok...

 

[Cobalt Phoenix]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

I don't friggin' know WHAT to say. If I did, I'd be helping with the cause to find scum. Jeez.

 

[Celever]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

I don't friggin' know WHAT to say. If I did, I'd be helping with the cause to find scum. Jeez.

You don't want to help with finding scum..?

 

[Kecleon-X]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

Here are all of Cobalt Phoenix's posts:

Spoiler

>LOL PRAISE ME
Oh boy, Sonicmoj is probably the annoying kid.

No contribution.

Whoa. Less than 2 hours in and Champ is already "voting" (or whatever Swagger actually does) for Camo. Confused status: kinda. If Machamp isn't actually voting, could he be a role blocker and/or a town drunk of some kind?

Alright here we see a confused person. Hasn't RVS'd apparently.

That feel when you leave for league and other things and don't have WiFi for the entire time. I just got home, so allow me to read the thread before giving an opinion. Okay?

No contribution.

@Theguy, to be honest, it's not like Drohn was around for "The Age of Kronar." That was like 2009-2011 ish. I highly doubt he researched the background to be able to forge a fake role description. I'm gonna hold off on voting for anyone until more evidence is presented.

No contribution.

Champ, I googled Random Voting Stage and found this link for RQS. Your Google-fu needs work, son.

No contribution.

Yeah, Guy. I did a tad a research and he was 2006-2009. To those wondering, Kronar was someone who mainly stuck to the chatrooms. He started the "adding random funny bits of chatlog into your bio" meme that still continues today. Kronar tended to be funny at all times while active. I can't think of anything else that's memorable about him, so if anyone else was around then, please feel free to add.

No contribution.

I can agree with that. Drohn, I'm sorry. I kinda have to go with the majority here. There's a lot of evidence pulling me towards ya.
##Lynch: Drohn

Can we get a vote count?

Hammered and obvious bandwagoning.

May I ask what "hammered" means? Also, 100% townie. If y'all would like my role pm, let me know. It's funny, I have a role, but it feels like it's worse than a vanilla townie. I dunno.

Why didn't he google this? No contribution.

It's not like I counted before hand. I even asked for a vote count.

Okay, incoming best role pm EVAR!!!111!

Best thing ever Amirite?

Also Champ, I'm actually not new to this. My first game was back in 2009's WW4. I've just had a lot of random crap impeding my chances of getting back into this.

How is this worse than a VT? Why claim when I'm the only one attacking him?

Camoclone said
>CP is probably scum
I just wanted to protect myself. Nothing more.

Just defending himself no contribution.

It's true. I CAN"T prove it. So let's flip it then. YOU can't prove you're not scum either, can you? If you can, present your evidence.

AtE...

Because lynching another townie makes a WHOLE LOT OF SENSE. If I was scum, don't you think I would try to CONCEAL my role, instead of just throwing it out in the open willy-nilly? I did it, so y'all could get off my backs. First the anonymous message is targeting me, and now, you are too. I'm sure we're still in RQS, but I have no reason to be nervous. I know I'm innocent.

Key word here is another townie. We haven't lynched a townie yet. And extreme AtE.

I'm a defensive person, thank you very much. I'll stop if that makes you feel better. And actually, it's two peeps. The Anon from the Night 1 results and now you.

2 people is not a lot. Defending himself with no real contribution.

Geez Camo, maybe stop flip-flopping between the two of us? I Why am I lurking? I'm not, I was at work. It's kind of hard to clean restrooms AND type replies to your allegations . There's not enough evidence to accuse either KoN or myself of scum-like behavior. Chillax, bro. We have plenty of time. Now to read all of those posts :S.

No contribution just defense. And there is more than enough evidence to lynch both of you/.

Make sure you read all of that. It is very important. You will get a overwhelming theme after a while.

Holy cow! And this is literally all of his posts? I get not knowing what's going on -- I mean, I've been busy and unable to post for a couple of days, and as Athena said, this is really active on the weekends, but that's a bit extreme. I mean... Wow.

I don't friggin' know WHAT to say. If I did, I'd be helping with the cause to find scum. Jeez.

And then there is post.

If he wasn't scum, then why would he even say this?

I'm getting a newbie-town or newbie-wolf vibe from him, and because of that, I think I'll wait until he posts a defense. But until then, I'll abstain from voting. His role isn't what I'm after -- that can clearly be faked in this game, otherwise PMJ wouldn't have specifically stated so in the rules -- I'm after his logic.

 

[alex]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

[insert any of your names], you've played too many Werewolf games to not know that insubstantial posts simply means a new player, werewolf or town or indie, and that it tells you nothing about their role.

Only well thought out long posts with no actual opinion are worth analyzing this way.

 

[Teal]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

I don't friggin' know WHAT to say. If I did, I'd be helping with the cause to find scum. Jeez.

I was first like WHAT.

But then I understood what they meant by this.

But basically, you admit you are not of any help, huh.

 

[Camoclone]

RE: Werewolf XXI: The Members' Revolt. Day 2 ends May 22 at 12 PM CDT.

He still has yet to contribute anything. If you look at his posts about 10% of them have substance.

KoN is scummy but CP is more scummy... His posts have no substance if you look back.

Camo, you've played too many Werewolf games to not know that insubstantial posts simply means a new player, werewolf or town or indie, and that it tells you nothing about their role.

Only well thought out long posts with no actual opinion are worth analyzing this way.

I've played in enough games to know that new townies at least try to help even if their logic is bad. Not to mention if they don't even try to help then they are of no use (unless they have a PR).

I don't friggin' know WHAT to say. If I did, I'd be helping with the cause to find scum. Jeez.

There you have it guys... Can we please have more votes on him?