Bolt the Cat said:
professorlight said:
I'll take a serious, well developed RPG, please.
For PC and consoles, of course, no more short flash games or shitty mobile microgames.
This series has ALL the potential to make a great RPG, roguelike and more (not a shooter or fighting game, though) with good story, character development, gameplay, enemies, etc. Hell, I've even found this:
MLP: FIM RPG (boy, that's a big acronym)
Hopefully the big adult audience will steer the developers into a less "6 year old girl games" direction and into a more decent game.
RPG is fine by me, but I'd rather have something along the lines of an action/adventure or platformer, that seems like it would be a tad more natural to the series.
How? action/adventure games feature a lot of action and a fast paced story, while MLP has plots that are resolved mainly through words, which is one of the characteristics of an RPG (some others being several main characters, conversation trees, several special abilities or perks, some enemies, large parts without combat, etc). Try it, watch any episode and try to imagine how it would be as an RPG level, then as an adventure game, then tell me which one fits best.
I'm serious, tell me; with all the hibridization of genres going on lately, I can't be positively sure
any genre is completly out of the question... look at the android game, it's a goddamn
city builder, a kids story about six friends and friendship became a
city builder... how can that even happen? evidently it was easier to make, same with platformers and fighting games in PC, but it does not seem what the MLP universe calls for.
An example that comes to mind are the winx club games: same conditions, a young girls/teen show that was basically harry potter+fairies+fashion and glittery shit (wasn't as bad as it sounds, the first seasons, at least).
It got several games:
-the first was a sort-of-decent RPG, for GBA, PS2 and PC, about the first season of the show.
Lots of potential wasted, going in a
dumbed down "easier to understand and play" direction, but at least it wasn't your usual game for that market.
-the second was a side scroller, you fly and hit things, and can change between any of the six characters with their unique abilities, which didn't affect gameplay. There were also some minigames, I think.
-the third was the same as the second, but with even less story, only one playable character (I think) and more minigames
-then a bunch of secret diarys, and other assorted minigame crap.
-and aparently there's a fourth one I just found out about, again, a "fly and shoot" for android, Iphone and Ipad, this time in a 3d environment.
Notice a trend there? games oriented to girls tend to be much more dumbed down and shoehorned into genres that are not supported by the source material, I'm sick as f*** of that, and that's what I'm worried about here: those kinds of games have to come
after the appropiate genre games are successful. There'll be time to do MLP: FIM: hooves racing or MLP: brawl is magic, but first they must do MLP: the game,
and do it well.