skullvarnish said:
Well, in my limited experience, I'd say bet money on the next rotation being BCR-on. Boundaries Crossed has a few cards that are very important to the game that have not been reprinted. The good Squirtle, Landorus EX, and Skyla (not sure if the reprint in the Red Genesect Box would keep it legal) are all cards I couldn't see them getting rid of.
^ I agree with you on the fact that we need a total Skyla reprint of some form before we, as well as TPCi, can unanimously call BCR an outdated set when compared to the newer sets, and at the same time, ensure that the metagame does not change drastically post-rotation as a result, so I respect your opinion and share your pain...
...However, given that Noble Victories, which was the third and final set that was rotated out of the Modified format last September to form the NXD-On format that set the standard for the 2013-14 play! pokemon season, was released in Japan in july 2011, and released in the US in November that same year, and that Boundaries Crossed was released on the same month one year later(July in Japan, November in the US), it's likely that, unless TPCi announces something different to make such a projection irrelevant, we are on course for an undesirable rotation that will change the Pokemon TCG metagame drastically, because BCR, which brought us Skyla(yet, since it doesn't have a 100% replacement(sorry, Korrina), I feel the pain of having to let go of Skyla, along with bench-protected squirtle, and Landorus EX, which could be replaced by Lucario-EX, but without the bench-damaging capability), is likely to be the fourth(fifth if Dragon Vault is counted as a set) and final set to be rotated out to form the standards for 2014-15. Here are the things I bet you will be sad about if such projection is correct:
1. Goodbye, Rocky Helmet(or at least the non-Japanese version, as Japan has seen reprints that could negate those cards from being rotated out in the Japanese region, but I will ask: can they use such cards in Worlds if Rocky Helmet is rotated out in every other part of the world?). Without you, we will be forced to use rock guard if we want an attack deterrent that threatens with damage, but since Rock Guard is an ACE Spec, and Rocky Helmet is not...
2. Goodbye, Computer Search. Without you, we will be forced to utilize a Florges if we want to draw any card at will, but at least discarding two is not a factor with Florges, and those two discards that Computer Search requires can be replaced by two more deck draws than Computer Search offers if Florges is used to draw the card. However, since Florges is a stage 2 pokemon and Computer Search is an Item...
3. Hello, Furious Fists-caused damage acceleration. You have changed the game forever. Never before have we witnessed a set that features more than one or two player-manipulated ways to increase the damage done to opponents that dare to stop the fury. But can you stand a chance against Psychics using such acceleration? The answer to that question will reveal itself more and more over time, from prerelease to the 2014-15 Nationals...
^ The above may not be to your liking, but I will say that we will have to wait until the official rotation announcement before we know whether or not to say "Projections mean nothing when it comes to Pokemon TCG. Surprises may happen that defy projections and right the ship of game balance against predictions made before the fact"...In the meantime, did you get the above???
edit: Just because it's in a promotional box doesn't mean its remaining time in Modified is reset(or keep it legal beyond the time of set rotation out of Modified), in case you want an answer to your question...