No one would ever admit to being a mafioso.
If the vote seemed random, then it shouldn't be worth your response. The way you responded to it made you sound incredibly paranoid.
Finished Mafia XXXV: Pokemon Card GB3: Team GR's Last Stand
- Thread starter PMJ
- Start date
- Status
This makes sense. I just wanted an explanation from Drac, but I guess I could've thought out my response a bit better.
This also makes sense. No one would just go out and announce "I'm scum!"
Jesi, I was reading you as new town. I was overlooking the copious amount of WIFOM logic in your defense, reading it as genuine.
Then you made the post above. Agreeing with the prosecutor's logic does not help your case. >.>
Then you made the post above. Agreeing with the prosecutor's logic does not help your case. >.>
Jesi has shown that she knows the game though, even though she's only played in a few games. You shouldn't be reading her as new town.
So you admit your guilt then?
Exactly that. You have claimed that redirection ability could potentially be a town role. So why did you vote bbninjas as scum using that logic? Why did you call him scum when you yourself already said that it could be a town role? By that logic, aren't you disproving your own theory and own evidence for voting bbninjas?
That begs the question, why did you still call him scum and vote for him? My theory to that is in my previous post: Your intention is to make out bbninjas as scummy and start or push a town lynch on him - and that's a scum tactic. There's nothing wrong with having theories like you did. The suspect thing here is that in a neutral situation (like the redirection ability), you immediately jumped to and stuck to the conclusion that is negative and paints someone else as scummy.
No, not at all. I'm just saying "I understand where you're coming from with this." I don't know how that suddenly made me scum in your eyes.
Bah, should've taken that last part out. I don't mean it as in being paranoid. >_<"
That's not how defending yourself works.
Give me a reason not to lynch you. All you've done by saying "I understand" is reaffirm my decision.
And to add to what I said @Squirtle Squad , if my theory about you is wrong, then please state what are your other reasons (if any) for thinking bbninjas is scum aside from that theory about redirecting abilities.
Not ... necessarily. She knows the game, granted, but I'm reading it to be somewhere around where I was myself at the number of games she's played. A bit overconfident, and hasty to form conclusions. Her defenses seem to parallel that as well.
PP, did you post your thoughts on SS and SM yet? I might've missed it.
Well when you read only a select, specific part of my post then yes I can see how you would think what you've posted.
I said that I overall just feel bb to off. The possibility that he has a self redirect is just like a little cherry on top. It's not by any means the sole reason for my vote at all.
Why do you feel that way? Is it because of what you explained about bb's dropping the case on KX? If so, what is your response to bb's comment on that?
^This is what you didn't comment about, which is basically bb's response to your case on him.
My thoughts on SM are the same as they were yesterday: I think he's scum. I've already shared my reasoning.
I don't totally understand the case on SS so I have no opinions yet.
Do you think Jesi or SM would be the better lynch for today?
Then what are/is your other reason(s)?
It's basically that he said that bb could have an ability that can be used for both town and scum, then he voted bb for that, but apparently he also has other reasons so we're waiting for that.
Jesi today.
If I thought SM was the better lynch, I'd be voting for him.
I feel like I shouldn't be lynched because even though I do have some amount of experience in Mafia (third game now and my second game I was killed really early), I still have a lot of room to improve and learn, and by lynching me early I don't have the chance to learn from my mistakes and take that information into the next day. Sure, I've been making mistakes, but I'm still a relatively new player, and you have to keep that in mind. I promise to you guys that it's worth keeping me around in this game, and I promise I'll change the things that I'm doing wrong.
Ah, OK.
- Status